Release Date: July 17, 2012
Publisher: Little, Brown Young Readers
Source: BookExpo America (Publisher)
Alex and Conner Bailey’s world is about to change, in this fast-paced adventure that uniquely combines our modern day world with the enchanting realm of classic fairytales.
The Land of Stories tells the tale of twins Alex and Conner. Through the mysterious powers of a cherished book of stories, they leave their world behind and find themselves in a foreign land full of wonder and magic where they come face-to-face with the fairy tale characters they grew up reading about.
But after a series of encounters with witches, wolves, goblins, and trolls alike, getting back home is going to be harder than they thought.
This book is one that I can see myself rereading over and over again. I can see it becoming a favorite of mine. It was really well-written and thoughtful, humorous and delightful. It reminded me of Into the Wild by Sarah Beth Durst. Anybody willing to take a chance on this may find themselves pleasantly surprised. I know that I did, even though I had pretty high expectations for this book.
There were definitely some cheesy moments, but that was part of its charm. It was predictable (especially with its format, which was like a list of tasks and items that the Baileys had to accomplish before going home) but I don’t think it would be a problem to its intended audience. I feel like people are judging it a lot more harshly because it’s written by a star as opposed to a normal person.
It was sweet and thoughtful. Chris poured a lot into it and although some parts felt dragged out some or too confectionery as opposed to realistic, it sounds perfect for some of the kids that I know. I am a huge fairy tale fan so I really loved this retelling that took me back to another time and completely had me absorbed into the book.
I watched Chris Colfer deliver his speech at the Children’s Book and Author Breakfast and loved his personality. He was a gentleman, thoughtful, and clearly wasn’t like other celebrities who may just write a book for publicity. He truly cared about it and it was a dream of his. His speech was hilarious, he was polite, and came off really well. Before BEA, I had just heard of his book but wasn’t sure if I would end up picking it up. But his speech changed my mind and we ended up getting copies with the breakfast.
The Land of Stories: The Wishing Spell is the story of two twins – Connor and Alex – who lost their father the year before. While their family struggles to make ends meet, Alex and Connor are dreading their birthday which will surely just be them alone at home doing homework. When their grandma comes to visit and brings a book of stories that their dad used to read to them. When the twins discover that the book is magical (and accidentally fall through it!), they find themselves in another land.
It’s a land where Cinderella is pregnant, and every fairytale they’ve ever read is different! Alex wants to see everything before they go home, but how will they even get home? The twins hear about something called The Wishing Spell, involving obscure ingredients and travels around the kingdoms using only the help of a worn journal. When it turns out that the Evil Queen is after the same spell, it becomes more than a hunt for the ingredients – it becomes a race.
Anyways, the cute fantasy feel of it was completely indulgent. It was also much more intricate than I was expecting. Perhaps it’s from Chris’s work on the show, but he had a really good feel with twisting relationships and revealing shocking twists with ease. I couldn’t put it down; I read it completely in one sitting and found myself loving it.
This is a book that I will definitely be recommending to my school’s library and to some of the younger kids who ask me for book recommendations. It’s one of those books that I can see myself enjoying even when I’m older. It seems very much like a fairy tale – a bit classic in a way.
Read my extended review…
Alex and Connor have such a great relationship. They have their ups and downs but they’re really there for each other no matter what. They remind me of my sister Hannah and I when we were younger. They’re best friends no matter what. Hannah and I’s relationship has changed a little bit, but it still contains that carefree essence that comes across with Alex and Connor.
Alex is a braniac. She’s the girl that always raises her hand in class and deals with her classmates’ stares and whispers on a daily basis. Unlike her brother Connor, she doesn’t have a ton of friends and she isn’t funny. She just has her brain and uses her smarts a bit like a shield. She hides from the world and constantly spouts facts or has her nose buried in a book. She’s envious of Connor, who it all comes so easily to.
Connor has a huge group of friends and is one of the funniest guys in class. Unfortunately, he gets easily bored, often falling asleep, and finds himself struggling with his grades. He wishes that he was as smart as Alex and wishes that it came more easily to him.
Each twin wanted what the other had, but at the end of the day, they were there for each other and it was really heartwarming. Their mother worked double shifts on a daily basis and was never there however much she wanted to be. They had to sell their house after their dad died a few days before their birthday the year before, and have been struggling to get by ever since.
I loved how the fairy tale characters weren’t just plopped onto the page. There are some fairytale retellings that use the characters exactly how you’ve always seen them. Chris Colfer makes you re-examine your thoughts about classic characters. He puts them into settings that you’ve never seen before and really gives them personalities.
Alex’s reaction when she fell through the book was really priceless. I really do think that if I were stuck in a fairytale world, I’d want to go sightseeing too! She was actually excited when she found out where she was and I would be too. The excitement and energy of the twins was just contagious when they first found out that they were in a book!
Chris Colfer has some things to learn with his writing because sometimes he would tell instead of show, etc,. but it was really enjoyable. Chris doesn’t really give a lot of credit to the reader by explaining everything but I would definitely be satisfied if I were in the MG age group. He also had a habit of introducing other scenes with “…” after the previous scene which took me out of the story but it was okay. The writing could get better and I believe that I will read another book if Chris Colfer writes one. The picky book-reviewer side of me wanted to say that, but the normal part of me just really enjoyed the book.
I was really surprised by the character development and strength of relationships that really came through at the end of the book. Connor and Alex really had a tough year with their dad and they had some differences that were slowly resolved throughout the story. There was one really emotional scene towards the end of the book that just made me want to hug the twins. The loss of their father was a huge part throughout the book but it was handled really well.
I am a really huge fan of fractured fairytales and Chris Colfer does an excellent job dragging out some more obscure ones. There were some that I hadn’t thought about in a while like Jack and the Beanstalk and he managed to tangle them together with ones that are used a lot to create new ones. Red Riding Hood was spoiled and Goldilocks was a fugitive.
Another thing that I really enjoyed about the book was that there were some really good quotes in there. They were upfront and sweet. I may write a few on my walls. There were a lot of thoughtful passages that spelled things out a little too obviously for my taste but were great messages. It also didn’t feel like lectures as opposed to messages. I really enjoyed it.
Alex and Connor were really relatable in different ways. Alex was the smart one and Connor was the social and funny one. Alex wasn’t as relatable to other people and that’s something that I identified with. Connor was convinced he was dumb, especially compared to Alex. I also always love reading about twin relationships (although it is really hard to pull off well, Chris Colfer did a really great job!). This book made me feel younger again and more innocent than I am now. It was cutesy and cheesy in some moments but a bit profound in others.
I’d say that this was meant for younger readers (towards the younger end of the MG scale) but that’s not to say that you won’t enjoy it if you’re a teen or adult or even older middle-grade reader. You just might notice a few more flaws more prominently. It’s enjoyable and has potential in the series. It’s almost like Narnia crossed with Into the Wild crossed with Shrek.
It was pretty funny at times. There were some references and jokes that some younger readers might not get but had me cracking up. It wasn’t uproarious but it was humorous even in the worst situations, which I really enjoyed. Chris Colfer has this way of putting a spin on even the most insignificant details in the story and having it all come around in the end to make sense. The ending felt a little weak to me but I really enjoyed it and I loved learning about some of the villains!
Overall, The Land of Stories: The Wishing Spell was a delightful and imaginative take on the fairytales that I know and love (and several that I had forgotten about until reading this!). It’s definitely a feel-good book and I was surprised by the amount of backstory and intricacy that popped up. The writing was pretty good but I would definitely recommend it mostly for the younger set. It was a bit flawed but it was enjoyable enough for me to read in one setting and love it.
Recommended for anybody who loves: Shrek; Into the Wild; The Chronicles of Narnia; retellings; feel-good stories; etc,.
No book club questions for today!